When Should You Apply for Social Security? Consider All the Consequences
Nearly 72% of men who filed for Social Security in 2009 opted for early benefits, up from 58% in 2008. More women also filed–74.7% in 2009 compared with 64.2% in the previous year.
Are you considering joining them in 2010? Before you decide to take the easy money in these hard times, know that the early option results in a significant negative impact to the amount of your benefit.
First, let’s get a little perspective.
The full retirement date (that is, the age at which seniors qualify for 100% of their Social Security benefit) for people born in 1937 and prior, is age 65. Retirement dates gradually increased by two months every year until they reached age 66, and then were held there for people born from 1943 through 1954. A similar pattern begins for those born in 1955 through 1959, adding two months per year, until birth years beginning in 1960 and beyond have a full retirement age of 67.
So, now that you know your full retirement age, how does that matter?
Applying for benefits at age 62 will permanently reduce your monthly benefits by 25%. Whether that works to your favor depends on how long you live. The longer you draw Social Security, the less of a benefit starting early is over the balance of your lifetime. Starting your benefit between age 62 and your full date will increase your monthly benefit by a prorated portion of that 25%. If we could predict our life expectancy, this calculation would be much easier to determine!
If you have the patience to wait and the funds from other sources to live on until your full retirement date, then you will have another decision to make at that time. By waiting until you are 70 or later to start drawing that benefit check, you will get a large increase over those extra years, up to 32% extra. More patience and an additional pile of money to live on will be needed to wait those extra three to five years. This table summarizes how waiting would benefit you.
| Year of birth | 1937 – 1938 | 1939 – 1940 | 1941 – 1942 | 1943-or later |
| Yearly increase rate | 6.5% | 7.0% | 7.5% | 8.0% |
So with a 25% benefit for waiting past age 62 and another 32% for waiting until age 70, you will get a 57% benefit for waiting eight years. Not a bad return in this market! But take care of yourself, too, so you’re sure you’ll be living long enough to collect those bigger checks for the next decade or so.
If this all seems confusing, it gets even more complicated when you try to mix in variables of how much your spouse would be eligible for at different ages and the amount of taxes you might pay from these various benefits.
Despite these complications, a prudent decision requires consideration of all the facts. First, a vast resource of information is at http://www.ssa.gov. If need more information for your personal situation, your friends at Patrick & Robinson, CPAs are here to help; email or call us for an appointment: 904-396-5400.
Remember, Social Security is your personal benefit. Be smart in deciding when to apply for it.